Independent reviewed-draft decisions · remaining owner work
Saved review-decisions · Original source proposals/2026-10-09-continuation/research-review/section01/decisions.json · original SHA256 88aae8d44bedf635bc8530c222cd411c39ff18863fc0adbf758d4fa4a125a1e3 · immutable published snapshot proposals/research-artifact-archive/b48a8a3ca41f/88aae8d44bedf635bc8530c222cd411c39ff18863fc0adbf758d4fa4a125a1e3.json · SHA256 88aae8d44bedf635bc8530c222cd411c39ff18863fc0adbf758d4fa4a125a1e3
Bounded research/review evidence. This artifact does not certify physical manufacturing closure or later changed routes.
{
"review_id": "independent-five-bfs-review-2026-10-09",
"reviewer": "research_review",
"target_version": "v1",
"scenario_id": "coordinated-discovery-v1",
"original_assignment_revision": 52,
"original_scoped_revision": 53,
"original_author_check_revision": 69,
"review_initial_snapshot_revision": 74,
"review_final_snapshot_revision": 84,
"scope": "Exactly five same-item drafts; original section01 and amended section02. No sixth researched item.",
"report_identity_record": "final-audit.json",
"independently_opened_primary_sources": 13,
"immediate_obligations_preserved": 63,
"original_routes_unchanged_at_final_snapshot": true,
"original_and_amended_report_manifest_hashes_match": true,
"decision_semantics": "approved-as-draft / reviewed-as-draft approves corrective finding or bounded evidence draft only, not live mutation, inventory completeness, quantitative suitability, availability, route implementation, physical acceptance, terminal or closure.",
"operations": [
{
"id": "R01",
"original_decision": "approved-as-draft",
"amended_decision": "reviewed-as-draft",
"record_ids": ["handset", "battery-protection-electronics", "software-provisioning", "boot-and-development-tools", "hidden-joint-x-ray-inspection-equipment"],
"route_ids": ["discovery-handset-v1"],
"source_ids": ["H1", "H2", "H3"],
"rationale": "Module-specific mechanical/electrical/firmware compatibility, USB signaling and operator-interface requirements are supported; target values and allocation remain open.",
"required_owner_work": "Coordinator with domain owners: freeze measurable target; allocate cleaning/support/storage, test contacts, rejected/waste stock, battery protection placement and loading/X-ray overlap. Preserve all34 current immediate obligations through actual consumers.",
"remaining_status": "open"
},
{
"id": "R02",
"original_decision": "approved-as-draft",
"amended_decision": "reviewed-as-draft",
"record_ids": ["enclosure", "aluminum-stock", "precision-machines", "jigs-fixtures"],
"route_ids": ["discovery-enclosure-v1"],
"source_ids": ["E1", "E2"],
"rationale": "Commercial tablet RF splits and milling support/chip control are narrow precedents. They do not qualify generic cast aluminum, chosen alloy/temper, manual precision or a mandatory insert.",
"required_owner_work": "Mechanical/radio: freeze drawing/material; allocate cutters/wear/chip collection/cleaning and lubricant or supported dry-cut method. Validate RF interfaces only for chosen geometry; compare alternate inventories separately.",
"remaining_status": "open"
},
{
"id": "R03",
"original_decision": "needs-correction",
"amended_decision": "reviewed-as-draft",
"record_ids": ["covers", "polymers", "molding-equipment", "dryroom", "moisture-verification-instrument", "molding-die-set"],
"route_ids": ["discovery-covers-v1", "discovery-polymers-v1", "discovery-memory-molding-equipment-v1"],
"source_ids": ["C1", "C2"],
"rationale": "Amendment adds genuine small-batch cabinet and unreinforced Makrolon/Apec TVI alternatives while retaining quantitative moisture and grade-specific qualification gaps. TVI is screening, not a numerical low-water assay.",
"amendments_confirmed": ["R03-C1-01", "Retained polymer-film-extrusion-stretching-line selected construction obligation"],
"required_owner_work": "Mechanical/chemistry/facilities/metrology: select grade and conditioning/transfer path, qualify mold fill/clamp/vents/demolding/thermal capacity, allocate consumables and quantitative assay only where required. Current dew-point frontier is not pellet-water qualification.",
"remaining_status": "open"
},
{
"id": "R04",
"original_decision": "approved-as-draft",
"amended_decision": "reviewed-as-draft",
"record_ids": ["seals", "handset", "enclosure", "covers"],
"route_ids": ["discovery-seals-v1"],
"source_ids": [],
"rationale": "Direct record/caller comparison: fiber-packing preparation does not establish unfrozen phone ingress, optical or aging requirements. This is unqualified suitability, not universal physical impossibility.",
"required_owner_work": "Mechanical/facilities: define each seal's chemistry/contact/compression/environment/aging duty before adapting shared stock or requesting distinct state. Retain known seal reachability.",
"remaining_status": "open"
},
{
"id": "R05",
"original_decision": "needs-correction",
"amended_decision": "reviewed-as-draft",
"record_ids": ["cover-glass", "glass-strengthening-bath", "optical-metrology", "tongs", "supports"],
"route_ids": ["discovery-cover-glass-v1", "discovery-glass-strengthening-bath-v1", "frontier-optical-metrology-v1"],
"requested_identities": ["glass-stress-profile-instrument", "glass-edge-impact-and-bend-fixture"],
"source_ids": ["G1", "G2", "G3"],
"rationale": "Amendment correctly retains advertised profile features as manufacturer claims and actual-glass constants/range/uncertainty as unqualified; separates dynamic edge damage from subsequent four-point bending.",
"amendments_confirmed": ["R05-G2-01", "R05-G3-01"],
"identity_decision": "Approve as draft distinct capability requests compared with inspected microscope/length/joint/barrier/wheel functions; no ID insertion or physical qualification. Owner may justify extension instead.",
"required_owner_work": "Mechanical/facilities: cutting/edge/rinse, recipe/salt-contact vessel, handling/fuel/coupon/waste stock. Electrical/metrology: coupling optics/media, wavelength/fringe range, glass optical constants and independent references/host/power; distinct impact/bend geometry and force/velocity reference duties. G2 commercial mechanism is an example; earlier alternatives need their own evidence.",
"remaining_status": "open"
},
{
"id": "R06",
"original_decision": "approved-as-draft",
"amended_decision": "reviewed-as-draft",
"record_ids": ["display-panel", "display-substrate", "transistor-backplane", "display-oled-stack", "display-encapsulation", "flexible-interconnect", "display-gate-source-driver-set"],
"route_ids": ["discovery-display-panel-v1", "discovery-memory-transistor-backplane-v1", "discovery-display-oled-stack-v1", "discovery-display-encapsulation-breadth03-v1"],
"source_ids": ["D1", "D2", "D3"],
"rationale": "Repeated declared substrate/FPC rows and source-described deposition on a processed substrate justify a state/quantity ledger, not automatic deletion or three consumed sheets.",
"required_owner_work": "Facilities/display with electronics: distinguish bare/backplane/OLED/encapsulated intermediate, actual FPC/driver installation stage, extra trial stock and repeated containment/reuse. Preserve every true manufacturing requirement via actual consumer.",
"remaining_status": "open"
},
{
"id": "R07",
"original_decision": "approved-as-draft",
"amended_decision": "reviewed-as-draft",
"record_ids": ["display-panel", "display-encapsulation", "display-barrier-film", "display-barrier-polymer"],
"route_ids": ["discovery-display-panel-v1", "discovery-display-encapsulation-breadth03-v1"],
"source_ids": ["D2", "D3"],
"rationale": "Rigid lid/frit/laser and flexible TFE examples are distinct. Selected rigid/TFE compatibility/lifetime remains unproved but is not disproved by these sources.",
"required_owner_work": "Facilities/display: choose coherent stack and collect direct compatibility/thermal/chemical/lifetime evidence. Keep current selected TFE conditional/open and alternative lid/seal/preconditioning/laser/UV duties separate. Do not union recipes or remove unknown barrier obligations.",
"remaining_status": "open"
},
{
"id": "R08",
"original_decision": "needs-correction",
"amended_decision": "reviewed-as-draft",
"record_ids": ["display-panel", "display-oled-stack", "mask-making", "optical-metrology"],
"route_ids": ["discovery-display-panel-v1", "discovery-display-oled-stack-v1", "frontier-optical-metrology-v1"],
"unselected_candidate_routes": ["discovery-mask-making-v1"],
"source_ids": ["D1", "D2", "D3"],
"rationale": "Amendment preserves different RGB mask patterns, mask-set/count, installed carrier/alignment and conditional reticle-patterning reuse. Candidate mask apparatus is not selected available FMM capability; microscope is not photometric/barrier qualification.",
"amendments_confirmed": ["R08-D1-01", "Explicit unselected mask-making candidate construction route"],
"required_owner_work": "Facilities/display with mechanical and electrical/metrology: match chosen deposition/patterning mask stock/support/cleaning and independently referenced detector/spectral/stimulus/thickness/barrier-life tests; retain earlier physical host/loading/power.",
"remaining_status": "open"
}
],
"report_decisions": [
{"item_id": "handset", "original": "approved-as-draft", "amended": "reviewed-as-draft"},
{"item_id": "enclosure", "original": "approved-as-draft", "amended": "reviewed-as-draft"},
{"item_id": "covers", "original": "needs-correction", "amended": "reviewed-as-draft"},
{"item_id": "cover-glass", "original": "needs-correction", "amended": "reviewed-as-draft"},
{"item_id": "display-panel", "original": "needs-correction", "amended": "reviewed-as-draft"}
],
"discovery_feedback_decision": "Original research agent section02 feedback classifications independently inspected and approved as draft: declared inventory fact, method-supported obligation, unresolved decision/suitability. Reviewer discovery-feedback.md separately retains exact route examples and owners.",
"rejected_operations": 0,
"amended_reviewed_operations": 8,
"amended_reviewed_reports": 5,
"live_registry_mutations": 0,
"inventory_completeness_approvals": 0,
"quantitative_suitability_approvals": 0,
"executable_route_approvals": 0,
"accepted_physical_outputs": 0,
"endpoint_approvals": 0,
"closure_approvals": 0,
"gate_ready": false,
"target_acceptance_denominator": "unfrozen"
}